Electric Car vs Hybrid Car: If you are contemplating purchasing a vehicle but are confused about whether to opt for an electric car or a hybrid one, we have compiled a helpful guide today to assist you in making the right choice.
In the current market, numerous electric and hybrid cars have been launched, with many leading manufacturers entering the fray and offering vehicles that boast exceptional performance.
However, many people remain undecided regarding which type of vehicle to choose—hybrid or electric—and which option would best suit their needs, facilitate their daily commute, or fit within a specific budget while offering optimal value.
Therefore, today we will outline the key differences between these two categories. Let’s dive into the details.
Table of Contents
EV Vs Hybrid Car
Electric Car vs Hybrid Car: When comparing electric and hybrid cars, the issue of rising pollution plays a significant role. Consequently, many people prefer purchasing hybrid cars as a response to environmental concerns, while others opt for electric cars specifically to help reduce pollution levels.
Electric Car vs Hybrid Car: This situation often leads to considerable confusion regarding which vehicle to select and which powertrain is the most appropriate choice at this juncture. Currently, electric vehicles are gaining significant traction; however, the fast-charging infrastructure remains somewhat limited.
On the other hand, hybrid cars offer an excellent combination of petrol and electric power, making them particularly convenient for long-distance travel. If you find yourself torn between these two options, we are here to simplify the decision-making process for you.
To illustrate this, we have provided a detailed 5-year cost calculation—using the Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara Strong Hybrid as an example to help you make an informed choice. (Please note: This data has been sourced from an article published by News18 Hindi, and we are presenting these calculations to you in a simplified format.)
Hybrid Car
Electric Car vs Hybrid Car: Speaking of hybrid cars, the Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara Strong Hybrid stands out as an excellent option. This is a private passenger car. In terms of pricing, you can expect an ex-showroom price in the range of ₹16 to ₹20 lakhs.
Including insurance and other charges, the on-road price typically falls between ₹20 and ₹22 lakhs. The vehicle boasts an ARAI-claimed mileage of 27.97 kmpl.
When considering real-world efficiency, the city mileage ranges from 23 to 25 kmpl, while the highway mileage is observed to be between 20 and 22 kmpl. In terms of fuel economy, its 45-liter fuel tank provides a driving range of over 1,000 kilometers.
Electric Car
Electric Car vs Hybrid Car: Turning to Maruti’s first electric car—the eVitara—its ex-showroom price ranges from ₹17 lakhs to ₹19 lakhs. In Uttar Pradesh (UP), the on-road price is approximately ₹19 lakhs to ₹22 lakhs; this means you can purchase it at a lower price point compared to its hybrid counterpart.
The vehicle offers an ARAI-claimed driving range of 543 km. Regarding real-world efficiency and battery consumption, it is estimated to deliver approximately 6 to 7 kilometers per unit of electricity.
With home charging, the running cost is estimated to be around ₹1.12 per kilometer.
5-Year Cost Calculation
Electric Car vs Hybrid Car: Based on a 5-year cost analysis, the on-road prices for both the Grand Vitara and the Maruti eVitara remain comparable. However, the running cost for the Grand Vitara stands at ₹4.32 per kilometer (calculated based on ₹95/liter petrol and 22 kmpl mileage), whereas the Maruti eVitara costs just ₹1.12 per kilometer (based on electricity rates).
This translates to a saving of ₹2.40 lakhs with the EV model over this period. When comparing the total expenditure over five years, the Grand Vitara incurs a cost of ₹3.24 lakhs, while the Maruti eVitara… If the cost is ₹84,000, one can expect a saving of ₹2.40 lakh with the EV variant.
Furthermore, regarding maintenance costs over a five-year period, the Grand Vitara incurs expenses ranging from ₹25,000 to ₹30,000, while the Maruti Vitara falls between ₹15,000 and ₹20,000; this translates to an easily achievable saving of up to ₹10,000 with the EV.
Finally, considering the total expenditure over five years, the Grand Vitara entails a cost of ₹3.55 lakh, whereas the Maruti Vitara costs ₹1 lakh—resulting in a net saving of ₹2.55 lakh with the EV option.
